26. 2. 2010
RSS backend
PDA verze
Čtěte Britské listy speciálně upravené pro vaše mobilní telefony a PDA
Celé vydání
Archiv vydání
Původní archiv


Vzkaz redakci


Britské listy

ISSN 1213-1792


Jan Čulík


Karel Dolejší


Michal Panoch, Jan Panoch

Grafický návrh:

Štěpán Kotrba

ISSN 1213-1792
deník o všem, o čem se v České republice příliš nemluví
5. 11. 2009

"Small country" complex: stop telling Klaus not to bother the EU

If France could spend years fighting to forbid Germany to call tartar sauce „mayonnaise“, during the pre-history days of the European Community, why cannot Klaus dispute national sovereignty issues?

What is this understanding in Europe – accentuated in the countries of the former socialist bloc – that there is the need for a One Voice? Klaus is right to go against such frighteningly reminder of Kremlin-inspired puppet voting in the satellite countries.

A Czech version of this article in CLICK HERE

In the U.S., because of the conservatism of southern states, which are heavily influenced by puritan values, the ordeal to pass certain federal laws is epic and well known, from the desegregation legislation to the current fight for homosexual rights. Such prolonged processes have not kept the country from developing and thriving, though.

Why is it that bureaucratic-minded Europeans feel that there is the need for unanimous opinion on whatever issue? Why is it that Europeans think that discordance is aggression? So what if Klaus is fighting windmills with Jana Bobošíková as his Sancho Panza? Have not the French fought for their food and other traditions that often seem to us as silly?

What is wrong with Klaus being a populist and profiting from the psychotic aversion Czechs have towards the spectre of Sudeten Germans returning to their stolen homes? The fact that innocent German girls were raped (sometimes to death), underage German kids were submitted to horrors and even the sick and elderly were often barbarically and unfairly punished in the euphoric lawlessness of the immediate post-War months by cowardly Czechs, more often looking for material profit than justice, is a undefeated taboo subject in this nation.

Democracy without the freedom of believing stupid things and saying them out loud is not democracy. I consider any laws or cultural norms that come from fairy tales like the Bible or any other magical beliefs in superbeings as ridiculous, illogical and dangerous, but I cannot keep those who like such superstitions to believe or talk about them. If Klaus believes or pretends to believe that the Lisbon Treaty document would allow those horrible Germans to fight back for their rights, this is his right. A right given to him in the name of all Czechs by their parliamentarians. The fact that the group choosing and the persons available to be chosen are like from a Fellini comedy is your fault. It is the fault of every Czech who finds whatever alibi to not go out and vote.

Klaus is the president and we all knew he is against the EU, that he does not believe in human influence on global warming and that he is a Hussite. To then tell him to not be himself is at least contradictory.

We should not forget that the Lisbon Treaty is the fruit of political arrogance and is but a trick. It is a light re-issue of a democratically rejected proposal. It is a new name for a slightly manicured European Constitution project, which was refused in referendum by the French and the Dutch in 2005. That shows how undemocratic is the way of thinking in the high structures of the EU – if the "People" refuse something, wrap it up again and try to sell it once more. It looks to me too much like Hugo Chavez and his referendum for his socialistic constitution – after being defeated once, he waited a bit longer, put some make-up in the text and... new voting.

Not that I have anything special against the Lisbon Treaty. Like the vast majority of inhabitants of this continent, I have not had the time and patience to read it. And I never agreed ideologically with Klaus. But on the principle that he has the legitimate right to not agree with whatever he finds suitable we do actually agree.

I often meet Czechs who say they agree with Klaus, but thought he should not make waves and simply sign it. I guess it is a certain subconscious feeling that Czech Republic is too small or unimportant to stop a process wanted by so many much more important countries.

If Sarkozy disrespects all rules of EU diplomacy and acts independently of the institution’s guidelines, as when he flew to deal with Israel early this year, so why cannot Klaus also act controversially and independently?

If the EU wants to change Klaus opinion, they should not have resorted to force. It looked like all wanted to purge Klaus as a dissident was in the Soviet bloc. What else could Klaus want but to gain the status - for future generations - of a rebel against a suffocatingly politically correct institution? Democracy is about trying to convince those who have different views, not forcing them to pretend they have them. That is for dictatorships.

Klaus made his name known all over the world with each new episode surrounding his signature of the Treaty. In a twisted way, he put Czech Republic in the map. He acted with an air of superiority that makes some more powerful and richer countries see it as petulance, exposing their feeling of superiority. In a way, he stylized himself as Czech David against the imperialistic Goliath of Brussels. In a country with a history marred by foreigners telling you what to do, Klaus may have a point. But even if not, he should be allowed to make it openly and without the peer pressure that turns him into a pariah for seeing things differently. We should always beware of any general consensus. They tend to mask and disregard the details…

Havel signed, going beyond his powers and local public opinion, a document in support of George W Bush and his war against Iraq... Havel in some known cases took as much time as possible before signing a bill he was not happy about. Presidency, in parliamentarian systems, is all about symbolisms, once said Havel himself, comparing his role to that of an actor in a silent movie. Klaus is just playing his character and portraying the "Hommo Cechus" in the way this nation is known for: as a Herectical Czech, lending from the title of a The Economist article in January.

Klaus is representing well the small town Czech, who is suspicious of foreign authorities and distrustful of institutions. And who also love a conspiracy theory... If Italy can have a Berlusconni, why cannot Czechs have their own version?

Obsah vydání       26. 2. 2010
26. 2. 2010 Martin Myant: The future of the Czech economy doesn't need to be bleak
24. 2. 2010 The Impenetrable Walls of a Shameful Silence - Our media ad usum delphini? Karel  Dolejší
24. 2. 2010 Why the Czech media does not have great journalistic personas? Ivo  Šebestík
24. 2. 2010 Problems of Czech citizens on the border with Germany or are we not part of Schengen? Daniel  Strož
24. 2. 2010 We will have ethnic conflicts in Czech Republic Štěpán  Steiger
24. 2. 2010 Czech Telegraph Fabiano  Golgo
24. 2. 2010 For This Time... Pavel  Kopecký
24. 2. 2010 Has the Czech Science Academy succumbed to the government's pressure? Štěpán  Kotrba
24. 2. 2010 Czechs Flooding Polish Pharmacies to Acquire Pseudoephedrine Drugs
5. 2. 2010 Michael Moore's films "will not be allowed to irritate US tourists in Prague"
2. 2. 2010 Czech electricity supplier blackmails consumers using a combat unit
2. 2. 2010 The global economic crisis and the future of "remainder democracy" Karel  Dolejší
27. 1. 2010 There is no difference between current Czech politicians and the politicians of the communist era, says an opinion poll
25. 1. 2010 Czech culture in the current issue of the Edinburgh Review
25. 1. 2010 What is the Czech Republic about? Jan  Čulík
20. 1. 2010 Prostitution and human trafficking in the Czech Republic? Karel  Dolejší
11. 1. 2010 Czech Wikipedia is not impartial Fabiano  Golgo
29. 12. 2009 How the Czech internet daily Britské listy has become a slave to T-mobile Czech Republic
23. 12. 2009 Christmas, manipulation and the society of the “unknown others” Bohumil  Kartous
19. 12. 2009 Planet Earth, PLC Karel  Dolejší
8. 12. 2009 Prague firm BNV Consulting talks of sacking employees in its Christmas party invitation
4. 12. 2009 Employees in the Hyundai plant in the Czech Republic strike against inhuman working conditions Aleš  Uhlíř
24. 11. 2009 Baroness Ashton "took Soviet money"
5. 11. 2009 "Small country" complex: stop telling Klaus not to bother the EU Fabiano  Golgo
29. 10. 2009 Czech Consul General in Los Angeles criticises "anti-Czechoslovak book"
23. 10. 2009 Jan Fischer, Head of Czech caretaker government, commits the Czech Republic to the US missile base system without having a political mandate Karel  Dolejší
12. 10. 2009 Moscow asks for clarification of the new anti-missile defence configuration Karel  Dolejší
13. 10. 2009 Ne Základnám and Moving the Goalposts Sam Graeme Beaton
12. 10. 2009 Where is the problem of the Charter of Fundamental Rights Jana  Bobošíková
9. 10. 2009 Prague firm humiliates Romanies
23. 9. 2009 How deposed president Zelaya got inside the Brazilian Embassy in Honduras Fabiano  Golgo
19. 9. 2009 Obama's new anti-missile project will destabilise the international security system Karel  Dolejší
17. 9. 2009 The United States "to scrap the East European anti-missile project" Jan  Čulík
15. 9. 2009 The Czech general election "won't take place until spring 2010"
14. 9. 2009 A night in the police cells in Prague Olivie  Brabcová
14. 9. 2009 Czech police has dropped the charges against the apprehended journalist
13. 9. 2009 Czech police arrests a journalist Štěpán  Kotrba
10. 9. 2009 Czech Constitution Court has cancelled the early election
7. 9. 2009 International corporations are being subsidised from public resources Jan  Matonoha
8. 9. 2009 Czech Republic has given a suspended sentence to an internet journalist for "denying the holocaust" Jan  Čulík
2. 9. 2009 The Czech general election "may not take place in October" Jan  Čulík
7. 9. 2009 Václav Havel's Disharmony and his Politics of a Cosmic Order Michael  Hauser
7. 9. 2009 Hauser doesn't know what he is talking about Karel  Dolejší
2. 9. 2009 The Czech Republic as a Paedophile Paradise Věra  Říhová
23. 7. 2009 Chief Executive of Czech Public Service Radio has been dismissed
17. 7. 2009 Havel, Schwarzenberg and other East European politicians: Why did they write to Obama? Karel  Dolejší
18. 7. 2009 Are Brzeziński and Carter "anti-American extremists"? Karel  Dolejší
8. 6. 2009 The process which turned Milan Kundera into an informer Jakub  Češka
6. 3. 2009 The Crisis of Czech Literature Štefan  Švec
13. 7. 2009 Von Trier's test Ema  Čulík
10. 7. 2009 Cold Souls is cold and soulless Ema  Čulík
9. 7. 2009 An Attack On the Heart Ema  Čulík
7. 7. 2009 Another half-baked delight from the Czech film bakeries Ema  Čulík
24. 3. 2009 An "old" and a "young" view of the contemporary Czech Republic David  McCallum
5. 7. 2009 The Good, the Bad and the Ugly... Ema  Čulík
1. 2. 2009 Resources in English on Czech film, literature and politics
15. 2. 2009 More Czech resources in English
11. 12. 2008 On Russia and Chechnia John  Dunn
23. 12. 2008 Miloš Pick: When Credit Crunch Becomes Capitalism Crisis Miloš  Pick
22. 12. 2008 Miloš Pick: Prague Spring versus the 1990s Miloš  Pick
14. 8. 2009 Chavez and his religious followers Fabiano  Golgo
23. 3. 2009 Miloš Pick: Can Obama lead the world out of the crisis? Miloš  Pick
27. 11. 2008 President Obama's Foreign Policy: The Change We Really Want? Joanne  Landy

Evropská ústava a Lisabonská smlouva RSS 2.0      Historie >
16. 2. 2010 Eurozóna žádá od Řeků další škrty ve výdajích a nové daně   
15. 2. 2010 EU Řecku: Vysvětlete, jak došlo k zatajení dluhu   
15. 2. 2010 Německo odmítá myšlenku založení společného evropského fondu na pomoc Řecku   
15. 2. 2010 Řecko: Eurozóna potřebuje detailní plán záchrany členských států   
11. 2. 2010 Summitu EU dominuje řecká otázka   
11. 2. 2010 Reuters: Výsledkem dnešního summitu EU bude patrně jen politické prohlášení ve prospěch Řecka   
11. 2. 2010 Část představitelů eurozóny dosáhla dohody ohledně pomoci Řecku   
11. 2. 2010 Měnové trhy reagují na vágní příslib evropské pomoci Řecku poklesem   
11. 2. 2010 Řecko dostalo morální podporu, ne peníze - a krize pokračuje   
10. 2. 2010 Evropa patrně převezme záruky za řecké dluhy   
4. 2. 2010 Unie je uražena kvůli zrušení Obamovy účasti na summitu USA-EU   
6. 11. 2009 Golgo argumentuje nefér, Klause nikdo "neutlačuje" Hynek  Bíla
6. 11. 2009 Z národů ač jsme různých Bohumír  Tichánek
5. 11. 2009 Ke komu si chodí zahraniční zpravodajové pro informace? Ivo  Šebestík
5. 11. 2009 Francie: "Konzervativci Británii v Evropě vykastrovali"