30. 5. 2006
RSS backend
PDA verze
Čtěte Britské listy speciálně upravené pro vaše mobilní telefony a PDA
Reklama
Reklama
Celé vydání
Archiv vydání
Původní archiv

E-mail servis

Autoři

Vzkaz redakci

OSBL
Tiráž

Britské listy

http://www.blisty.cz/
ISSN 1213-1792

Šéfredaktor:

Jan Čulík

Redaktoři:

Karel Dolejší, Štěpán Kotrba

Redaktor anglické mutace Focus on the Czech Republic:

Fabiano Golgo

Správa:

Michal Panoch

Grafický návrh:

Štěpán Kotrba

ISSN 1213-1792
deník o všem, o čem se v České republice příliš nemluví
29.5.2006
United they fall

The ODS is polling ahead of the ČSSD, and the Greens might be the new kingmakers. But whoever wins the elections may still lose by forming a coalition of the unwilling.

A week before the June 2 contest, the main opposition Civic Democrats’ (ODS) lead over the Social Democrats (ČSSD) was within the margin of error, and it was anybody’s guess whether the Greens (SZ) would replace the centrist Christian Democrats (KDU-ČSL) as powerbrokers, or both would make it into Parliament. The latest polls show up to 15 percent of if the voters remain undecided or with no strong preference; the only near certainty was that the “new” Freedom Union (US) was history.

Published in Czech Business Weekly HERE

But whichever party emerges triumphant after the parliamentary elections, nowhere is it written that it will get to rule, and the battle to form a coalition government, the ultimate marriage of convenience, could rage for months to come.

Polls put the center-right ODS from 1.5 to 4 percentage points ahead of the left-leaning ČSSD of Prime Minister Jiří Paroubek, but in the 2002 and 1998 elections ČSSD was trailing even further behind its chief rival, yet won the day. All signs now point to a close contest, and barring another ODS- ČSSD “opposition agreement” – the remotest of possibilities, given that Paroubek and ODS party chairman Mirek Topolánek devoted much of their first television debate to trading insults, and refused to shake hands afterwards – a three-party coalition with a slim majority.

“It’s very similar to the situation four years ago, only now the Greens look set to replace the Freedom Union in the role of junior – and very unreadable – coalition member,” said Štěpán Kotrba, a political analyst for the Internet daily Britské listy.

A subject of great debate is just how loyal a coalition member the Greens would be, as they are considered both opaque and centrist, with their leader, Martin Bursík, having been a member of several other parties in the past, and seeming to side with ODS and ČSSD in the same breath.

“The Green Party hasn’t ‘identified’ itself, from the traditional parliament party point of view, and so is very unpredictable,” said political scientist Petr Just.

President Václav Klaus, the founder of ODS, criticized the Greens, calling them “an undefined grouping of independents,” a characterization party spokeswoman Eva Rolečková rejected, saying, “We have a platform, which is entirely consistent with the movement of the Greens who are in parliaments in 15 European countries.”

With Klaus’ ideological rival, former president Václav Havel, openly supporting the Greens, conventional wisdom holds that they are a greater threat to ODS and certainly to the “new” Freedom Union, which despite its “It’s legal” campaign and rebranding effort aimed at attracting young, disaffected voters, looked set to fall short of the 5 percent threshold of support needed to enter parliament (see “Down ‘n’ dirty, CBW, May 8, 2006). Polling at 5.4 percent, KDU-ČSL, could return to parliament, bolstered by their strong support base of conservative voters in South Moravia and South Bohemia. Those who have voted Freedom Union in past elections will likely be divided between Greens and ODS.

“There are a great number of possible coalitions,” Just said. “A lot will depend not only on the election results, but on the possibility to form a coalition. It’s not written that it must be the winner of the election who forms a government. The winner might be unable to form a (viable) coalition.”

Coalitions of the unwilling

Consistently the third-strongest party in parliament since 1989, the Communist Party of Bohemia and Moravia (KSČM), has never been part of a coalition government. But with the largely unreformed party polling at 13 percent — more than the Greens and KDU-ČSL combined — it is certain again to join ODS and ČSSD in the chamber of deputies. The only question is whether the Greens, or KDU-ČSL, or both will be in the picture, as pollsters see a larger swing vote than in previous contests.

“Developments at the end of the election campaign could be dramatic, because undecided voters will be shifting from one party to another and will also consider whether to go to the polls at all,” STEM polling agency Jan Hartl director told the Czech News Agency (ČTK).

Assuming that five parties, all but the Freedom Union, make it past the post, there are several possible coalitions.

If ODS wins it could well seek a coalition with the Greens and Christian Democrats, the perennial junior partner, now governing alongside ČSSD, but a member of each government during socialism as a part of the Národní Fronta, and responsible for the demise of two others these last four years. But, as noted, the Greens, apart from being environmentally conscious, are largely political unknowns with no pro-business track record. This highly volatile coalition would make sense only if the KDU-ČSL and Greens each obtain more that 10 percent of the vote, and ODS close to 30 percent.

The ODS and fellow conservatives KDU-ČSL could also try to go it alone, but as a minority government would have to seek ad hoc support ahead of every vote in parliament, and wouldn’t last long in power. ODS could also seek ČSSD’s tacit support, but that tact is also very risky, as the cases of former ČSSD Prime Ministers Vladimír Špidla and Stanislav Gross demonstrate.

Swing voters, “wasted” votes

The ODS could also win but be unable to find a coalition partner, and so lose, with the ČSSD winning over the Greens (natural allies of Social Democrats throughout Europe) and with the quiet support of the KSČM. But this too would be a very unstable left-center minority government.

Should the ČSSD come from behind to win, it could seek behind-the-scenes support of the Communists, which could prove a very stable de facto minority government. The Social Democrats has ruled out an official ČSSD- KSČM coalition. The ČSSD could also seek the ad hoc support of all parties: KSČM on social issues like health and education; the Greens on the environment; and ODS for problems of international and domestic security and business.

A ČSSD coalition with the Greens and KDU-ČSL — a kind of new anti-communist coalition — is highly improbable; Špidla took a similar route and his government nearly collapsed under pressure from the far-left wing of his party. Besides, the KDU-ČSL has twice brought a ČSSD-led coalition to collapse.

If the Greens or KDU-ČSL enter parliament, but not both, the equation is much the same: ODS and ČSSD publicly courting a small, troublesome party and privately looking to gain the favor of the Communists. The ODS or ČSSD could pair up with the victorious small party and seek ad hoc support on a range of issues, or, in the interests of securing a “stable political environment in the Czech Republic” — as the 1998 Opposition agreement put it — form the ultimate marriage of convenience.

“People have rather been flirting with support for the Greens,” the pollster Hartl said, adding that after “sobering up” some voters had shifted back to the ČSSD. If enough undecided or swing voters fear a vote from the Greens or Christian Democrats will be a wasted protest vote, the right-leaning will vote ODS, with the left going to ČSSD and KSČM, which again would mean a victorious ODS could still end up the opposition to a Social Democrat minority government with the support of the KSČM.

Irena Ryšánková is a parliamentary analyst for public broadcaster Česká televize

Obsah vydání       30. 5. 2006
30. 5. 2006 Staly se Britské listy cílem dezinformační hry, anebo předseda výboru pro obranu a bezpečnost Parlamentu Jan Vidím zatajil poslancům důležitá fakta? Štěpán  Kotrba
30. 5. 2006 Poslance Váňu z ČSSD zmlátili surově železnou tyčí
30. 5. 2006 Dopis televizních ředitelů Klausovi, který Martin Krafl odmítl zveřejnit
30. 5. 2006 KSČM filmaře ve Sněmovně podpořila a podpoří znovu Ivana  Levá
30. 5. 2006 Zelení vyhodí místopředsedkyni. Setkala se s Paroubkem.
30. 5. 2006 Kasl napadl objektivitu průzkumů STEM Štěpán  Kotrba
30. 5. 2006 Zakažte České televizi předvolební pořady :) Bohumil  Kartous
30. 5. 2006 DOKUMENT: "Braňme demokracii proti pučistickým praktikám ODS!" Jiří  Paroubek
30. 5. 2006 DOKUMENT: Výzva Mirka Topolánka
30. 5. 2006 S Paroubkem růst, s Topolánkem dluhy Jiří  Havel
30. 5. 2006 Nejasnosti v majetkových poměrech Martina Bursíka
30. 5. 2006 Nohavica se přiznal, že Hutka spolupracoval s StB :) Bohumil  Kartous
30. 5. 2006 Michael  Marčák
30. 5. 2006 ČTK: Ukázková manipulace mediální kočkou Filip  Rožánek
30. 5. 2006 Nekupujte vodu v lahvích
30. 5. 2006 Čelný liberálnědemokratický poslanec vyšetřuje smrt dr. Kellyho
30. 5. 2006 Havárie amerického vozidla vyvolala v Kábulu nepokoje
30. 5. 2006 Čtenáři nesou kus odpovědnosti za to, co čtou Bohumil  Kartous
30. 5. 2006 Napsali mi ze Slovenska přátelé Egon T. Lánský
30. 5. 2006 Poslanecká imunita Jaromír  Hájek
30. 5. 2006 Ve sbírce zítra vyjde novela vysílacího zákona Štěpán  Kotrba
29. 5. 2006 Cesta do hlubin filmařovy duše Filip  Rožánek
29. 5. 2006 Malé upřesnění k rovné dani Jan  Hošek
30. 5. 2006 Školné a ekonomické bariéry v přístupu ke vzdělávání Petr  Staněk
30. 5. 2006 Keňa zavedla zákaz kouření ve veřejných místnostech a na veřejných prostranstvích
29. 5. 2006 Týdeník Euro: Čechům plány na americkou základnu v ČR nevadí
30. 5. 2006 Kdy jindy než teď Jiří  Pazdera
30. 5. 2006 Mají čeští náckové hudební sluch? Lubomír  Valenta
30. 5. 2006 Ředitelka Ligy lidských práv jmenována řádnou členkou Rady vlády ČR
29. 5. 2006 United they fall Irena  Ryšánková
30. 5. 2006 Asociace školských odborů hodnotí 8 let vlády ČSSD Radek  Sárközi
30. 5. 2006 Střet zájmů Vladimíra Justa Ivan  Brezina
30. 5. 2006 Členství v NATO je závazek
29. 5. 2006 Media Tenor: Mezi "negativním popisem" a "poškozováním" je zásadní rozdíl Marek  Síbrt
29. 5. 2006 Sovy nejsou tím, čím se zdají být Štěpán  Kotrba
29. 5. 2006 Filmařská sprostota a 111 hlasů dobrých Štěpán  Kotrba
29. 5. 2006 Princip veřejné mediální služby a meze Janečkova intelektu Štěpán  Kotrba
29. 5. 2006 Témata Britských listů - nejen pro předvolební poučení
29. 5. 2006 Volby dopadnou špatně Boris  Cvek
29. 5. 2006 Volební kampaň jako hledání nenulových součtů Michael  Kroh
29. 5. 2006 Zdravotnictví: výhodně nízké mzdy, králíci a zajaci Ivan  David
29. 5. 2006 Dzurinda pred volbami: Strach pred Ficom Lubomír  Sedláčik
28. 5. 2006 Koho volit? Jan  Čulík
6. 5. 2006 Hospodaření OSBL za duben 2006
22. 11. 2003 Adresy redakce

České volby v roce 2006 a povolební pat RSS 2.0      Historie >
30. 5. 2006 Kasl napadl objektivitu průzkumů STEM Štěpán  Kotrba
30. 5. 2006 DOKUMENT: "Braňme demokracii proti pučistickým praktikám ODS!" Jiří  Paroubek
30. 5. 2006 S Paroubkem růst, s Topolánkem dluhy Jiří  Havel
30. 5. 2006 ČTK: Ukázková manipulace mediální kočkou Filip  Rožánek
29. 5. 2006 Sovy nejsou tím, čím se zdají být Štěpán  Kotrba
29. 5. 2006 Volby dopadnou špatně Boris  Cvek
29. 5. 2006 Princip veřejné mediální služby a meze Janečkova intelektu Štěpán  Kotrba
29. 5. 2006 Malé upřesnění k rovné dani Jan  Hošek
29. 5. 2006 United they fall Irena  Ryšánková
29. 5. 2006 Filmařská sprostota a 111 hlasů dobrých Štěpán  Kotrba
29. 5. 2006 Zdravotnictví: výhodně nízké mzdy, králíci a zajaci Ivan  David
28. 5. 2006 Bylo by zavedení rovné daně politickou sebevraždou? Jan  Čulík
28. 5. 2006 Štěpán Kotrba dezinterpretoval analýzu Media Tenoru o politických stranách Marek  Síbrt
28. 5. 2006 Dotaz na Marka Síbrta Jan  Čulík
28. 5. 2006 Koho volit? Jan  Čulík